The author: Professor Yasser Metwally
INTRODUCTION
July 11, 2009 — Direct evidence of a meningioma may be discerned from plain skull films in a remarkably high percentage of patients. in one-half of patients harboring meningioma the diagnosis could be made radiologically, The cardinal signs of meningioma are: [1] hyperostosis, [2] increased vascularity, and [3] tumor calcification. It is our belief that the presence of any one of these cardinal signs properly observed and evaluated can be adequate for the diagnosis of meningioma. Any two in combination or any one together with evidence of increased intracranial pressure can reliably establish the diagnosis of meningioma.
In general hyperostosis and enlarged vascular marking are much more likely to occur in the syncytial or angioblastic meningiomas,while calcifications are much more likely to be found in the transitional or psammomatous meningioma types
-
Hyperostosis
Hyperostosis is the first and most frequent direct evidence of meningioma. The new bone formation occurring in the neighborhood of a meningioma is a reactive change in the skull and not an integral part of the tumor.The exact mechanism of hyperostosis is not well understood ,however it is necessary for tumor cells to invade the overlying bone to invoke hyperostosis, the density of the change found in some cases and the difficulty of identifying tumor cells in the densely hyperostotic area may denote a bone reaction out of proportion to the quantity of invading tumour cells.
Figure 1. Postcontrast CT scan [left] CT scan bone window [middle] and plain x ray [right] showing bone hyperostosis and increased vascular marking
The inner table of the skull, the diploic space,and the outer table all may be involved in the hyperostotic process. In any given case, any one alone of these portions of the skull may be most conspicuously involved or multiple areas may be implicated. The inner table, however, is by far the most common cranial layer to be affected
Figure 2. Postcontrast CT scan [left] CT scan bone window [middle] and plain x ray [right] showing bone hyperostosis and increased vascular marking
The hyperostotic process takes place through the laying down of bone in multiple sheets parallel to the plane of the tabular cortex. In radiographs, the changes involving the inner table will appear as an area of extra density when viewed face on, whereas in tangential view the change will present as an enostosis. In the en face projection, the density will obscure normal bony architecture in the area of thickening, whereas the tangential view will demonstrate the intact nature of the diploic space and outer table if the hyperostosis is isolated.
Isolated hyperostosis of the inner table of the skull is most common in the presence of meningioma of the cerebral convexity and parasagittal areas.True alteration of bony architecture usually occurs with involvement of the diploic space. It may become only hypertrophied with preservation of the spongy architecture. More often, however, obliteration of the spongy appearance takes place through the deposition of large amounts of compact bone within the diploic area. Hypertrophy of the diploe may be related to increased vascularity within it, whereas sclerosis may be related to the infiltration of the Haversian system
Involvement of the outer table with the production of an external mound of bony tissue(and often a clinically detectable mass) may be seen but is most common in the thin portions of the skull where the inner and outer tables are in close approximation. Thus, although it is uncommon for a palpable mass to be present in the case of convexity meningiomas, exophthalmos is an expected finding in patients with meningioma of the sphenoid ridge. Such flat tumors, lying along the sphenoid ridge where there is essentially no diploic space, result in a marked bony thickening along both the inner and outer tables,
-
Enlarged meningeaL vascular markings
The second of the cardinal manifestations of meningioma is increased vascularity. This change occurs essentially as frequently as hyperostosis and, when properly evaluated, its significance can be just as important. The increase in vascularity takes two different forms: (1) an area of localized increased vascularity, hypervascularity, or neovascularity of the bone in the area of the tumor,and (2) enlargement of the vascular channels either supplying or draining the tumor area. The latter occurs more commonly than the former, but neovascularity is considered a much more specific change. Statistics regarding altered vascularity occurring in plain skull films are of little significance, however ,since , for the most part only those tumors occurring in distal areas provide the opportunity for such changes to be visualized. Thus, the great majority of tumors exhibiting abnormal vascularity are those of the cerebral convexity and parasagittal areas.
|
Figure 3. Plain x ray showing increased vascular marking and bone hyperostosis |
With basal tumors, visualization of the blood supply of the tumor in plain films is infrequent, even though it may be as abundant as in the case of tumors of the vault. Neovascularity may occur in only a small area beneath the tumor and be significant. More often, however, the hypervascularity presents a rounded or oval pattern, measuring several centimeters in diameter. The basic gross pathologic change is the perforation of the skull by many small arteries and veins extending to and from the tumor. The development of this neovascularity results in the presence of a multitude of small punctate radiolucent areas, a condition that is often referred to as stippling. Occasionally, stippling alone will be present beneath the tumor, and for all practical purposes it may be considered a diagnostic sign of meningioma.In the majority of cases, however, other changes will be found in the general vascular pattern, and it is common to find hyperostosis in association with a localized patch of neovascularity
Enlargement of the meningeal vascular channels occurs even more often than stippling, and,in the majority of instances when stippling is found, enlargement of the meningeal vascular channels is present also. The most frequent and important changes occur along the course of the middle meningeal artery; the anterior and posterior meningeal arterial pathways are less conspicuous radiologically. The two basic changes that occur in the middle meningeal groove,which carries both the meningeal artery and veins, are: (1) unilateral enlargement of the main vascular channel and (2) abnormal branching.
|
Figure 4. Plain x ray showing increased vascular marking and bone hyperostosis. |
Evidence of enlargement may be found at the point where the middle meningeal artery enters the skull through the foramen spinosum. The foramen can be oval as well as round.,The established range of normal for the shorter diameter of the foramen spinosum is between l.5 and 3 mm, with an average of 2 mm, as seen in basal radiographs of the skull. However, considerable variation on the two sides often occurs and it is not uncommon to find a larger foramen spinosum even on the side opposite the tumor. By itself, therefore, the presence of a large foramen spinosum cannot be considered a reliable diagnostic finding. A more consistent abnormality is widening and tortuosity of the channel of the middle meningeal artery as it crosses the floor of the middle fossa.The groove courses forward and lateralward from the foramen spinosum to the lateral edge of the greater sphenoid wing before ascending onto the vault. The size and configuration of the channel can be assessed on basal skull radiographs; the channel is enlarged with basal meningiomas and meningiomas of the sphenoid ridge.
Great importance can be attached to the appearance of the main middle meningeal channel as it courses upward and backward over the vault of the skull. An enlarged channel may maintain a straight course, but in other instances it may be unusually tortuous. Tortuosity of this vascular groove is an important radiologic change often found in patients with meningioma, and it usually denotes enlargement and elongation of the artery.
A slight degree of tortuosity of the middle meningeal groove is not uncommon in normal cases, but mostly in the initial portion of the trunk of this artery as it begins its ascent in the region of the greater wing of the sphenoid. In the normal case, the tortuous segment is short, 1-2 cm in length,and in the majority of instances is not associated with any suspicious increase in the width or prominence of the groove. In the lateral view, an enlarged meningeal channel appears as a wider,deeper (and therefore darker) shadow, and more sharply marginated than normal, or as compared with the groove on the opposite side.
The enlarged channel often remains of evenly increased diameter until the level of the tumor on the vault is reached, rather than tapering or narrowing as it arborizes.
The most important feature of enlargement of the middle meningeal channel itself is unilaterality. Whenever there is a discrepancy in appearance, with one middle meningeal channel more conspicuous in either the frontal or stereoscopic lateral radiographs, the case must be regarded with high suspicion. Some normal variation does occur, but, unfortunately, the absolute limits of normal and the normal range of dissimilarity of the middle meningeal channels on the two sides are not well defined. When only the main channel is prominent on one side,it is to be expected that in a fairly sizable group of patients no clinical or other evidence of intracranial disease will be found. However,whenever asymmetry exists, it is incumbent upon the neurologist to make a very careful search tor other evidence of intracranial disease,routinely through the careful study of the ordinary projections and also through study of additional views as required, particularly additional stereoscopic pairs of films.
It must also be kept in mind that both middle meningeal vascular grooves may be enlarged, and, under these circumstances, both may be quite conspicuous but relatively symmetrical. Meningiomas of the falx and of the parasagittal areas are the most frequent to invoke such a bilateral change and bifrontal tumors may also result in symmetrical enlargement .
Another significant alteration in the middle meningeal vascular channel that favors the diagnosis of meningioma is abnormal arborization.As visualized radiologically, the main channel of the middle meningeal artery courses upward and slightly backward posterior to the coronal Suture, and the great majority of normal branches seen are posterior ones which course upward and backward over the surface of the parietal bone. Although some normal anterior branches are present, they usually do not cause conspicuous markings or grooves in radiographs. Whenever anterior branches of a middle meningeal artery are found extending forward over one side of the vertical portion of the frontal bone, we tend to regard them with suspicion. In these cases, a careful search should be made at the termination of the rostral meningeal branch for evidence of other local changes such as stippling or hyperostosis which might confirm the suspicion of meningeal tumor or for evidence of increased intracranial pressure.
In general, it may be stated that whenever a branch is conspicuously larger than an adjacent groove from the same parent vessel, it should be regarded as highly suggestive of an abnormality.Posterior branches of unusual size are also to be regarded with question. For the most part, such abnormal vessels arise from the main middle meningeal trunk and extend to the parietal convexity or the parietal parasagittal region, the chief normal posterior branch of the middle meningeal usually arises from the main vessel along the base of the skull.Its groove frequently can be seen coursing upward across the temporal squama and then curving backward to spread out over the posterior half of the parietal bone and even into the occipital area. However, the secondary and tertiary subdivisions of the posterior branch of the middle meningeal artery are not ordinarily as conspicuous in radiographs as are the branches of the main trunk. The posterior branch may be enlarged with meningioma and also with certain other vascular lesions of the posterior regions,such as an arteriovenous malformation.
Venous enlargement in the diploic space often is a more difficult finding to evaluate than changes in the arterial channels. The diploic veins form a generally constant pattern anatomically, extending downward over the vault and communicating freely with intracranial venous structures as well as extracranial ones through emissary foramina. Radiologically, however, the veins appear less constant and there is considerable variation between patients with regard to the prominence or conspicuous nature of various diploic trunks. The diploic veins have been a popular subject of study for many years and there is considerable radiological literature concerning their appearance. Generalized prominence of the diploic veins usually is not of pathological significance. Some skulls are extremely vascular to the extent that the term “phlebectasia” has been coined to describe them. The main clinical significance of such a finding is troublesome bleeding that may develop with intracranial surgery in such cases
-
Tumor calcifications
The third cardinal finding for the diagnosis of meningioma is tumor calcification. Its occurrence has been reported variously.Most authors observers have described an incidence of something less than 10%.The extent of calcification shows marked variation radiologically, just as it does pathologically. The most common type of calcification evident is a cloudlike, globular shadow of increased density resulting from the conglomeration of multitudes of psammoma bodies.
Figure 5. Plain x ray skull [right] showing a heavily calcified transitional parasagittal meningioma
In some instances, the entire tumor may be fairly evenly opacified . At other times,the calcification appears to occur predominantly about the tumor margin or in one quadrant of the tumor Thus, the plain films may reveal not only the identity of the tumor but its extent without the necessity of contrast study. A radiograph of the pathologic specimen often will allow superimposition of the tumor shadow on the radiograph of the living subject.In some tumors, unfortunately, the calcification is of nonspecific type rather than a homogeneous conglomerate collection of psammoma bodies. Branching plaques of calcium may be present which resemble calcification in granulomas or glial tumors. In other instances, true bone may be formed, as may occur with other degenerative changes. In our experience, conglomerate psammoma calcification is the type encountered in the majority of instances.
Figure 6. CT scan studies showing heavily calcified meningiomas
There appears to be no special site of predilection for the development of fibrous meningiomas exhibiting calcific changes. Such tumors are encountered arising along the vault, particularly parasagittally, in the region of the tuberculum sellae and in the floor of the middle fossa. It is doubtful that the limited number of calcified tumors available to any one observer would contradict the general incidence of global, fibrous tumors arising in various sites.
References
-
Metwally, MYM: Textbook of neuroimaging, A CD-ROM publication, (Metwally, MYM editor) WEB-CD agency for electronic publication, version 10.3a July 2009 [Click to have a look at the home page]